Essentially, you’re saying: “I can’t explain why your numbers are wrong. I can’t point out any specific mistakes you made. I can’t refute your arguments, but somebody else made different calculations in a different way and, for reasons that I cannot explain, I like his numbers and dislike yours, so now it’s your job to study this other person’s calculations so that you can figure out why I think they’re better than yours.”

Weak to say the least.

— David Grace